james hardie siding on red residential home

James Hardie Siding vs LP Smartside (Pros and Cons)

author profile picture

Posted By:OpenBox Team

Are you a homeowner in need of siding replacement or installation?

There are a few stand-out siding brands on the market right now, two of which we suggest, and maybe you are already considering between the two. But which one should you go with?

Today we’re going to outline: James Hardie siding vs LP Smartside.

In this comparison, we’ll take a look at James Hardie and LP Smartside to determine what sets each apart. We’ll discuss the pros and cons of both in detail. That way, homeowners like yourself have all the required information to make the best decision.

Let’s jump right into our comprehensive overview of these two popular siding options!

James Hardie Siding: What Is It?

closeup of James Hardie siding option installed on home in grey color

James Hardie siding is made of fiber cement, which is a mixture of cellulose fibers and cement. It is a good choice if you are looking for a health-conscious siding option. The cellulose fibers contain sand and wood pulp, which have low levels of toxicity. Not only that, but James Hardie has been a leader when it comes to removing asbestos in its products.

Since this siding is made of fiber cement, it’s a heavier material. It looks good on the side of homes, and it’s durable.

3 James Hardie Siding Pros ✅

James Hardie offers numerous advantages. Here are a few of them:

1) Minimal Maintenance

One of the most attractive features of James Hardie siding is that it’s low maintenance. Since it’s made from fiber cement, you don’t have to worry about the boards cracking or rotting.

As you know, termites can wreak havoc on a home, especially when it contains siding made from wood. But you won’t have that problem when you install fiber cement siding.

2) Durable

James Hardie fiber cement products were designed to withstand water damage and tough climates. If you want siding that will last, James Hardie is the way to go.

3) Easy to Clean

It’s super simple to clean Hardie siding. All you have to do is rinse it off with water. If it needs a little more attention, you can pressure wash it. It’s that easy!

3 James Hardie Cons ❌

teal siding with durable james hardie home siding

While James Hardie offers incredible siding options, it has its drawbacks. Some of its disadvantages include:

1) Not Derived From Green Material

If you are someone who prefers eco-friendly products, James Hardie siding wouldn’t be the best option. It’s not made from the “greenest” materials. Therefore, you may have to bypass this option if you’re concerned about the types of products used on your home.

2) Heavy

On one hand, it’s good that James Hardie siding is dense. However, that also means that installing it takes more extensive labor, and installation could take longer. However, if you choose a professional contractor, like Open Box Roofing, you should have no problems.

3) Upfront Cost

Compared to other options, this siding product is more expensive. You’ll likely pay more for it upfront than if you were to choose another type of siding.

But keep in mind, James Hardie is built to last. Even if you pay more upfront, your siding material will remain intact for years to come. Plus, most contractors offer financing options that make home repairs more affordable.

LP Smartside: What Is It?

closeup of home with LP Smartside siding installed in white color

In contrast to James Hardie siding, LP Smartside contains coated wood strands that make them more resistant to moisture. It also includes zinc borate, which helps to shield the siding against insects and rotting.

LP Smartside siding has a very natural, wood-like appearance, which is great for homeowners who prefer that look.

3 LP Smartside Pros ✅

Just like James Hardie, LP Smartside has its pros. Below are some of the good things you can expect from it:

1) Green

In contrast to its opponent, LP Smartside is green. The primary ingredient used is wood, meaning that’s derived from renewable source material. It does contain resins and binders, but they are safe and low-emitting.

2) Termite Resistant

One of the biggest issues that homeowners face is pesky termites. The good news is, LP Smartside siding is manufactured in a way that prevents damage from termites. This is a huge plus because it means that the life of your siding will be longer.

blue home siding with lp siding installed

3) Available in Long Lengths

LP Smartside siding is generally available in long lengths. Therefore, you won’t have to order as many pieces to get the job done. That means a lower cost and quicker installation.

3 LP Smartside Cons ❌

As with anything, there are downsides to LP Smartside. A few of its not-so-good qualities are:

1) Contains Organic Material

While organic material is a plus, it also has its disadvantages. Since LP Smartside products include organic materials, it means that the siding could potentially burn.

2) Flaking

In most cases, the manufacturer of this brand doesn’t coat the siding. It’s generally done by a contractor. Therefore, the coating could flake if it’s not done properly.

3) Potential Termite Damage

While LP Smartside siding is designed to prevent termite damage, it doesn’t mean it’s 100% effective. And, if you happen to live in an area where termites are common, your warranty may not cover the damages.

James Hardie Siding vs LP Smartside: Which Is the Better Option?

siding contractors installing james hardie siding in neutral color

Overall, your best bet is James Hardie. It’s built to last, so your siding should remain intact for many years. The brand offers numerous options, so there’s something for everyone.

Not only that, but since Hardie material is easy to maintain, you won’t have to worry about regular upkeep. Honestly, it offers the most bang for your buck.

Need New Siding? We Can Help

If your home needs an exterior makeover, let Open Box Roofing do the job for you! Our professional, highly-skilled team has experience with installing all types of siding, which ensures that your home will look amazing.

With a variety of James Hardie siding options available to suit your taste, we’ll work closely with you to ensure that your vision becomes a reality.

Don’t wait any longer to transform your property, call us at 317-619-9001 or contact us via our website. We can’t wait to help you create the perfect look for your home!

family happily sitting down for dinner on lawn outside blue house

Don’t Think, Just Call Pink!

Let's Chat