close up of residential asphalt rooftop with flashing

7 Highest-Rated Asphalt Shingles For 2023 (Compared)

author profile picture

Posted By:OpenBox Team

As a savvy homeowner, you know that choosing the ideal roofing materials is crucial for both your home’s aesthetic appeal and long-term protection. With countless options available, finding reliable and high-performing asphalt shingles can be overwhelming.

That’s where we come in! We researched, compared and compiled the top 7 highest-rated asphalt shingle brands for 2023 – making it easier than ever to pick a winner that will elevate your home’s curb appeal and withstand harsh weather conditions.

If you want to choose the best shingles for making quality roof repairs or installing a whole new one, keep reading!

Key Takeaways

  • Investing in high-quality asphalt shingles for your roofing needs is crucial for durability, longevity, and energy efficiency.
  • The top seven highest-rated asphalt shingle brands for 2023 are: GAF Timberline HDZ Shingles, Owens Corning Duration Shingles, CertainTeed Landmark Shingles, Malarkey Legacy Shingles, Tamko Heritage Shingles, Atlas Pinnacle Pristine Shingles, and IKO Cambridge Shingles.
  • When choosing the ideal brand of shingle materials that suit your budget and preferences best be sure to consider factors like material composition (fiberglass or organic), resistance properties to harsh weather conditions such as hailstones and UV rays. It’s also important to compare pricing between the brands selected since it can vary depending on type and quantity needed. Comparing warranties offered by each manufacturer will shed light on anticipated lifespans so you know what to expect from their products in terms of performance over time.

Importance of Choosing High-Quality Asphalt Shingles

Investing in high-quality asphalt shingles is crucial for every homeowner, as it ensures the durability and longevity of the roof while increasing overall property value.

Roofing materials protect your home from various elements, such as harsh weather conditions, water damage, and debris.

Opting for higher-end roofing materials like luxury asphalt shingles can provide benefits beyond aesthetics. Their increased thickness allows for longer lifespans compared to standard 3-tab or architectural shingles; some premium options have been known to last 30 years or more before needing replacement.

In addition to these practical advantages, selecting top-tier asphalt shingle brands can contribute positively towards energy efficiency: certain products reflect solar heat away from your house instead of absorbing it, keeping indoor temperatures cool during hot summer months without placing excessive demand on air conditioning systems.

Criteria for Choosing the Highest-Rated Asphalt Shingles

new asphalt roof on a vinyl siding house

Selecting the highest-rated asphalt shingles is a critical decision that can significantly impact the durability and aesthetic appeal of your home. Consider several crucial factors to ensure you choose the best product for your home.

The material composition plays a significant role in determining an asphalt shingle’s longevity and performance under different atmospheric conditions. Typically made from fiberglass or organic materials coated with mineral granules, high-quality options provide enhanced endurance against harsh sunlight exposure, temperature fluctuations, algae growth on roof surfaces, among other elements.

Furthermore, asphalt shingles must demonstrate exceptional resistance to external hazards such as fires and high winds for maximum safety assurance.

Finally yet importantly – consider both upfront costs and long-term value offered by various brands before settling on one option; cheaper alternatives might seem appealing initially but could entail higher expenses associated with future repairs or replacements due to inferior build quality.

Comparing warranties provided by manufacturers can shed light on anticipated lifespans: some companies offer limited lifetime warranties, whereas others may only cover specific defects over set timeframes.

Top 7 Asphalt Shingle Brands For 2023 (Compared)

In this section, we will compare and evaluate the top-rated asphalt shingle brands for 2023 based on their ratings, reviews, features, and benefits to help you choose roofing material for your home.

GAF Timberline HDZ Shingles

GAF Timberline HDZ Shingles stand out as one of the top 7 asphalt shingle brands for 2023, thanks to their impressive blend of beauty, durability, and long-lasting warranties.

Known for manufacturing high-quality roofing materials, GAF continues to be a prominent player in the US roofing industry.

Homeowners who opt for GAF Timberline HDZ Shingles can expect not only an aesthetically pleasing roof but also exceptional protection against weather elements. In fact, installing these lifetime architectural shingles on a larger single-family home with a roof area of 3,000 sq.

  1. has been deemed a cost-effective choice by industry experts like Hook Agency’s Best Roof Shingles Guide. Additionally, GAF offers strong warranty options to back up the quality and performance of their products – ensuring your investment is well protected over time.

Owens Corning Duration Shingles

Owens Corning Duration Shingles are a multilayered roofing option that offers long-lasting durability and curb appeal.

What sets Owens Corning Duration Shingles apart from other brands is their limited lifetime warranty that covers manufacturing defects, algae resistance, wind damage, and more.

Consumer Reports has also rated them highly for their impact resistance against hailstones.

CertainTeed Landmark Shingles

CertainTeed Landmark Shingles are among the top asphalt shingle brands in the industry. They are known for their durability, beauty, and overall high-quality performance.

These shingles feature a dual-layer design that provides added protection against impact and wind damage.

One of the notable features of CertainTeed Landmark Shingles is their limited lifetime warranty. This guarantees homeowners that their roofing investment will last for years to come without any manufacturing defects or issues.

Not only do these shingles provide reliable protection from harsh weather conditions but they also boost curb appeal and add value to homes.

Malarkey Legacy Shingles

Malarkey Legacy Shingles are regarded as premium, high-quality products in the roofing industry. These shingles are made with SBS polymer modified asphalt and fiberglass matting, providing excellent resistance to extreme weather conditions.

While Malarkey Legacy Shingles may be more expensive than traditional asphalt roofing brands, they offer superior durability and longevity. The shingle’s unique design makes it resistant to cracking and blistering caused by direct sunlight exposure or heavy hail impacts.

Additionally, Malarkey offers a limited 50-year warranty on these shingles’ performance against manufacturing defects.

Tamko Heritage Shingles

Tamko Heritage Shingles is one of the top-rated asphalt shingle brands for 2023. These shingles come in a range of designs and colors that are sure to complement any home’s aesthetic.

What sets these shingles apart from other manufacturers is their innovative granule technology. Tamko uses a special blend of colored granules that enhance the roof’s appearance while providing long-lasting protection against UV rays and weathering.

Additionally, the brand offers a limited lifetime warranty on all their products.

Atlas Pinnacle Pristine Shingles

Atlas Pinnacle Pristine shingles are considered to be one of the best roofing shingles made by Atlas. These high-end, multilayered shingles offer exceptional durability and protection against harsh weather conditions.

In addition to their superior performance, Atlas Pinnacle Pristine shingles also come in a range of colors and styles that can complement any aesthetic preference. With exceptional fire resistance and resistance to manufacturing defects, these luxury asphalt shingles offer long-lasting beauty and protection for residential and commercial roofing projects alike.

IKO Cambridge Shingles

Among the top-rated asphalt shingles for 2023 is the IKO Cambridge Shingle. Consumer Reports has consistently recognized it as one of the best roof shingles on the market.

These roofing materials are made of a fiberglass mat coated with mineral granules and asphalt that provides excellent durability to face harsh weather conditions. The shingles have an architectural look, making them visually appealing for residential homes.

IKO Cambridge Shingles come in various colors and styles, including dual-layered laminated architectural designs that mimic natural slate or wood shake roofing materials at a lower cost.

One of the downsides is that they may not be suitable for regions with extreme temperature fluctuations as they might crack over some time due to their thickness compared to other brands’ thicker options on this list.

Cost Comparison of the 7 Asphalt Shingle Brands

houses with colorful sidings and asphalt shingle roof in suburbs

After evaluating the top seven asphalt shingle brands for 2023, it’s crucial to consider how much you’ll be spending. Although affordability is one of the key reasons homeowners choose asphalt shingles over other roofing materials, prices can still vary depending on the brand and type of asphalt shingle.

Starting from our top pick GAF Timberline HDZ Shingles, which are among the most popular architectural shingles in America today, a 30-year lifetime warranty costs between $120 and $160 per bundle.

Meanwhile, Owens Corning Duration Shingles range from $125 to $150 per bundle with a comparable warranty period of 25-30 years.

Malarkey Legacy Shingles stand out due to their high-quality fiberglass composition and are priced between $130 to $155 per square foot – this does not include installation costs by roofing contractors.

Tamko Heritage Shingles offer various colors and designs but are amongst cheaper options costing around $100-$110 per square with Limited Lifetime Warranties available upon request (usually about a will last at least fifty years).


Choosing the right asphalt shingles for your roof is an important decision. With so many options available, it can be difficult to know where to start. But by considering factors such as durability, cost, and style, you can narrow down your choices to the top-rated brands available in 2023.

The list of seven highest-rated asphalt shingle brands compared in this article includes some of the most reliable names in roofing materials, including GAF Timberline HDZ Shingles and Owens Corning Duration Shingles.

Each brand offers unique benefits that cater to different homeowner preferences and budgets.

family happily sitting down for dinner on lawn outside blue house

Don’t Think, Just Call Pink!

Let's Chat